2016 - Kevin Pierce -- Trevecca University
2016 - Tyler Delgato -- Trevecca University
2014 - Kent Katzman -- Southern Indiana
2014 - Kurt Pierce -- Cumberland University
2013 - Nick Durbin -- Martin Methodist
*Member of the 2013 NAIA National Championship team
2012 - Anthony Brayer -- Lee University
2012 - Seth Harter -- University of Indianapolis
2012 - Shane Powell -- Martin Methodist
*Member of the 2013 NAIA National Championship team
2010 - Nick Dykes -- East Tennessee State University
2010 - Blake Farmer -- Carson-Newman
